Calamari
$16.00
This appetizer features squid, though its preparation is not specified.
“The calamari is the best in town! And the tomato sauce is superb👏👏👏”
Italian Appetizers
Sausage Stuffed Mushroom
$15.00
A mushroom filled with sausage, served as an Italian-style appetizer.
“Owner Walter, waitress Shannon et al were inviting. Eclectic menu. Fried Provolone as well as Sausage stuffed Mushrooms not on a lot of menus. Delicious. Fettuccine and Penne Alfredo a must.”
Fried Provolone
$10.00
Fried provolone is a crisp, melty cheese appetizer.
“Every aspect of this dining experience is amazing!! Fried provolone appetizer is creative and flavorful. Seafood fra diavolo is spicy like it should be and seafood is cooked perfectly. If you haven’t been GO!”
Mussels White
$16.00
Mussels are shellfish served as an appetizer at Nonna's.
“Wonderful quick dinner before a show next door at the Paramount. Mussels in white sauce- Perfect; Salads with salmon- outstanding! Very nice and friendly staff; the owner greeted us at the door. Top notch. Thankyou- we will be back!”
Salads
Pasta
Alfredo
$21.00
Pasta in creamy Alfredo sauce, with pasta shapes and add-ons optional.
“The food was excellent! We had Alfredo, Chicken Piccata and Lasagna and each dish was perfect. Like that they are open on Mondays. Our server and the other staff were friendly and efficient.”
Eggplant Parm
$28.00
Eggplant layered with red sauce and cheese; pasta is an optional addition.
“Delicious eggplant parmigiana, freshest salad accompanied by warm bread with garlic & oil and a wonderful red wine to accompany my meal. The owners and staff were welcoming with smiles and a great meal followed. Welcome to Downtown Rutland!”
Chicken
Chicken Parm
$28.00
Breaded chicken topped with tomato sauce and melted cheese.
“First of all the staff were amazing. I believe it was the owner who greeted us at the door and got us seated. The servers were very on top of everything making sure everyone was satisfied. Me and my wife split the chicken parmesan and the kitchen even gave us separate plates, it was very unexpected but appreciated. Prices were very reasonable for both food and experience. Highly recommend for any special occasion.”
Chicken Piccata
$29.00
Chicken in lemon-caper piccata sauce, with pasta available to select.
“As someone who doesn't care for pasta or chicken I have become the biggest fan of their chicken piccata! The calamari app was cooked to Perfection not chewy at all, impressed with the red sauce underneath... another Italian product I'm not too keen on normally. In the late '80s I was head chef at mama choffee's cellarette in Reading Pennsylvania... a quaint little Italian restaurant... the food at Nonna's brings me back there! Food and service is fantastic at Nonna's... don't just go by my word, come down check it out you'll see.”
Chicken Marsala
$30.00
Chicken served in Marsala wine sauce, with optional soup or salad.
“Shocked that this place was nearly empty on a Thursday evening. Very good Italian food at reasonable prices. Minestrone soup will taste different than any you've had, I'd bet. Great service and the owner was a great host.”
Red Sauce Chicken
$21.00
Chicken with red sauce; pasta shapes are available as optional choices.
Seafood
Salmon Piccata
$32.00
Salmon in lemon-caper piccata sauce, with pasta available to select.
“Everything about this restaurant was 5 star!! From the nice gentleman who sat is to all the wait staff..all top notch. If you’re in the area and looking for an amazing meal with perfect ambience I highly recommend Nonna’s!! Superb!! Had the hummus plate appetizer, salad and don’t even get me going about the bread and garlic oil dip..could’ve ate that’s the meal itself. My family and I all decided on the Salmon Picatta and WOW! So many flavors, absolutely delicious! Chefs kiss! 5 stars all the way!!”
Seafood Fra Diavolo
$32.00
Seafood in spicy tomato sauce, with pasta available by choice.
“I virtually fell into comfort upon entering Donna's I was met with great service and the fra diavolo was outstanding”
Desserts
Tiramisu
$9.00
Espresso-soaked ladyfingers layered with mascarpone cream and cocoa.
“The chicken parm was delicious and came with lots of sauce. The sauce has good flavor and tastes homemade. My boyfriend got the lasagna and it was also very good and a generous portion. The bread was very yummy. However, the dessert stole the show. The tiramisu is AMAZING. It’s light and fluffy and perfect.”
Scoop Chocolate Gelato
$6.00
A scoop of chocolate gelato, a dense, Italian-style frozen dessert.
“We finally got around to trying Nonna's and I was seriously impressed by how good the food is. It was definitely the best Italian food I've had in VT. I'm looking forward to making this one our regular places to eat out.”
